ZIONISM / YISHUV EY-----shitas tosfos
He writes (p. 149, 150) that the
"However, ALL THOSE WHO FOLLOWED TOSFOS REJECTED THE WORDS OF RABBEINU CHAIM FROM HALACHAH, see Shelah...."
Now he is correct that the Shelah disagrees with Tosfos, which makes it a Machlokes, which we all knew before. There are those who reject the Tosfos, for sure. But his statement that all subsequent authorites rejected Tosfos from Halachah is simply a joke. The following is a partial list of places where you see he just isn’t telling the truth:
(1) The Taz (EH 75) brings the Tosfos without mentioning any opposing positions, indicating that he rules like Tosfos l'halachah
(2)
(3)
(4) Tumas Yeshorim 66 quoted in B'er Haitev EH 75 defends Tosfos' position l'halachah and says since it is a legitimate Machlokes, nobody can demand that someone go to
(5)
(6)
No comments:
Post a Comment